Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kassandra (they/them)'s avatar

I can appreciate a lot of this post - but I have to argue with the idea that people misgendering you (or anyone) is a reflection of some kind of onus on the trans person to somehow get better at being trans (apologies if this isn’t what you intended to say - but that’s the way this read to me). This might be a way to look at it if you are a binary trans person whose ultimate goal is to pass, but this isn’t ever going to be an option for nonbinary people like me and it is never going to be achievable by binary trans people who just are never going to pass. I have a very dear friend who, no matter that she always dresses very feminine, has long hair, has done the voice training and acts like every other white woman I know - is just never going to pass. She knows this, but that doesn’t take the sting out of being misgendered constantly, despite the obvious fact that she is presenting as a woman. For my part, I am 6’3” and built like a viking. Even if I were to do what I want to do and get on HRT and become as feminine as possible - I will never be mistaken for a woman.

As for McBride - she isn’t misgendered as an honest mistake because there is something about her the world doesn’t see as a woman. I honestly think she passes really well. I think that if people didn’t know she was trans they wouldn’t assume she was trans. In fact I think this was proven when one of the “brave and righteous” TERFs on Capitol Hill thought they were scoring a victory by harassing someone in the women’s restroom that they THOUGHT was McBride, but it turned out was a cis woman. Because no matter what anyone says - they can’t “always tell”. I don’t think it is about “forcing” people to buy what you’re selling - I don’t think it is about trying to socially pressure people into treating you with respect - I think it is about calling people on their bull$#!+. I don’t bother correcting people because I’m not allowed to if I want to keep my job - but that doesn’t mean I’m doing something wrong by not being enough of what I want the world to see in me.

Expand full comment
seahorsemafia's avatar

The serenity prayer of all things has been a reoccurring theme throughout my transition. I’ve said before that being a trans is a master class in the concept of acceptance.

You accept the things you cannot change , because if you don’t you’ll be miserable or go crazy.

It’s also been a master class in the concept of joy from simple things . Ask any cis person when was the last time a stranger using sir or maam absolutely made their whole day?

The flipside of that coin is there are so many ordinary, simple things that can also cause pain now.

Being referred to as brother or son or my old name used to not be a blip on my radar, where now it’s a painful reminder of how im viewed in the eyes of ppl who’s opinions I care about, and wish were different.

You’ll get to know your inner workings to a degree many people aren’t otherwise forced into considering.

Good article🤍

Expand full comment
36 more comments...

No posts